Things that make your Website appear Untrustworthy

by | Jun 25, 2024 | Articles

Did you know that 94% of first impressions on a website are design-related? This startling statistic highlights just how crucial trustworthiness is for online businesses. A website that appears untrustworthy can drive potential customers away in seconds, undermining your efforts to build a successful online presence.

Trust is the foundation of any online business. Without it, even the best products or services will struggle to gain traction. Factors like the website’s UI/UX play a significant role in establishing this trust, as does the overall presentation and functionality. Investing in professional web design services can make a substantial difference in how visitors perceive your site.

In this blog, we will explore the key elements that can make your website appear untrustworthy and provide practical tips to address these issues. From poor website design and slow load times to inconsistent branding and lack of social proof, we’ll cover it all to help you create a trustworthy online experience for your visitors.

Poor Website Design

The design of your website is crucial in forming visitors’ first impressions. A poorly designed site can quickly deter potential customers and reduce your brand’s credibility. Here are key aspects to watch:

Outdated Layouts

  • Dated Aesthetic: An old-fashioned layout makes your site look neglected and unappealing.
  • Navigation Issues: Confusing navigation frustrates users.

 Lack of Professionalism

  • Amateurish Elements: Inconsistent fonts, mismatched colors, and low-quality images make your site look unprofessional.
  • Cluttered Layouts: Overcrowded pages overwhelm visitors.

Mobile Unfriendliness

  • Non-Responsive Design: Websites not optimized for mobile devices drive users away.
  • SEO Consequences: Poor mobile optimization affects search engine rankings.

Investing in web design services ensures your site remains modern and user-friendly. Improving the overall website UI/UX and focusing on content optimization can enhance your online presence and build visitor trust.

Slow Load Times

Slow load times can significantly impact your website’s performance and user satisfaction. Here are the key issues related to slow load times:

Impact on User Experience

  • Frustrated Visitors: Slow websites lead to a frustrating user experience, causing visitors to leave before exploring your content.
  • Increased Bounce Rates: Users are likely to abandon slow-loading pages, resulting in higher bounce rates without effective website optimization.

SEO Implications

  • Search Engine Rankings: Slow load times negatively affect your search engine rankings, making it harder for potential customers to find you.
  • Reduced Traffic: Poor SEO performance leads to decreased organic traffic, highlighting the need for proper website optimization.

Ways to Improve

  • Professional Help: Leveraging WordPress web design services can enhance your website’s speed by optimizing code, images, and overall performance.
  • Content Delivery Networks (CDNs): CDNs can distribute your content more efficiently, reducing load times for users around the globe.
  • Regular Maintenance: Ongoing website optimization can significantly improve load times and user satisfaction.

Inconsistent Branding

Inconsistent branding can undermine the credibility of your website and confuse visitors. Here are key issues related to inconsistent branding:

Mismatch in Visuals and Content

  • Confusing Visitors: A mismatch in visuals and content can lead to confusion and a lack of trust among visitors.
  • Professional Assistance: Leveraging web design services can help ensure consistency across all branding elements.

Importance of Cohesive Branding

  • Consistent Colors, Fonts, and Messaging: Maintaining uniform colors, fonts, and messaging is crucial for cohesive branding.
  • Expert Help: Engaging WordPress web design services can enhance your website UI/UX by ensuring a cohesive visual identity.

Lack of Contact Information

Not providing clear contact information can make your site seem untrustworthy and unprofessional. Here are key issues related to the lack of contact information:

Perception of Secrecy

  • Trust Issues: Hiding contact details can create a perception of secrecy and make visitors wary.
  • Transparency: Web design companies can help ensure that contact information is prominently displayed, enhancing trust.

Importance of Transparency

  • Clear and Accessible Information: Providing easily accessible contact information is essential for building trust.
  • Optimization: Web design services can improve content optimization by making contact details more visible and user-friendly.

Leveraging web design services can help you achieve these goals effectively.

No SSL Certificate

The absence of an SSL certificate can significantly harm your website’s security and trustworthiness. Here are the key issues related to lacking SSL certificates:

Security Risks

  • Insecure Perception: Without SSL, your site appears insecure to visitors, making them hesitant to share personal information.
  • Professional Setup: Web design services can help implement SSL certificates to secure your site effectively.

Trust Indicators

  • Importance of HTTPS: Displaying HTTPS and security badges reassures visitors about the safety of their data.
  • Enhanced Credibility: Web design companies can assist in showcasing these trust indicators prominently.

Poor Content Quality

Quality content is crucial for establishing credibility and engaging visitors. Here are the key issues related to poor content quality:

Grammatical Errors and Typos

  • Undermining Credibility: Errors and typos can make your site seem unprofessional and reduce trust.
  • Content Optimization: WordPress web design services can help ensure your content is polished and error-free.

Outdated or Inaccurate Information

  • Keeping Content Current: Outdated or incorrect information can mislead visitors and damage your reputation.
  • Regular Updates: Website optimization practices include regularly updating content to maintain accuracy.

 Value of High-Quality Content

  • Engaging and Informative: Well-researched, high-quality content adds value and keeps visitors engaged.
  • Professional Writing: Web design services often provide content creation and optimization to ensure quality.

Intrusive Ads and Pop-Ups

Too many ads and pop-ups can ruin the user experience and drive visitors away. Here are the key issues related to intrusive ads and pop-ups:

Negative User Experience

Annoying Visitors: Excessive ads and pop-ups frustrate users and lead to higher bounce rates.

Seamless Integration: WordPress web design services can help manage ads in a way that doesn’t disrupt the user experience.

Trust Issues

Desperate Appearance: Overloading your site with ads can make it appear desperate for revenue, reducing trust.

Balanced Approach: Website UI/UX experts can find a balance that monetizes without alienating visitors.

Lack of Social Proof

Social proof is essential for building trust and credibility. Here are the key issues related to lacking social proof:

Importance of Reviews and Testimonials

Building Trust: Reviews and testimonials from real customers can significantly enhance trust.

Showcasing Feedback: Web design companies can help integrate these elements into your site effectively.

Displaying Trust Badges and Certifications

Reassuring Visitors: Trust badges and certifications signal reliability and professionalism.

Visibility Matters: Website optimization includes strategically placing these badges for maximum impact.

Missing Privacy Policy and Terms of Service

Having clear legal documents is crucial for transparency and trust. Here are the key issues related to missing privacy policies and terms of service:

Legal Implications

  • Compliance: A privacy policy and terms of service are legally necessary to protect your business and customers.
  • Professional Guidance: Web design services can assist in drafting and displaying these documents.

Building Trust

  • Reassuring Visitors: Clear and accessible policies reassure visitors about how their data is handled.
  • Transparency: WordPress web design services can ensure these documents are easy to find and understand.

Poor Navigation and Broken Links

Navigation issues and broken links can frustrate users and make your site seem unprofessional. Here are the key issues related to poor navigation and broken links:

User Frustration

  • Difficult Navigation: Complicated navigation systems frustrate users and drive them away.
  • Improved Website UI/UX: Web design companies can streamline navigation for a better user experience.

Impact on Trust

  • Neglected Appearance: Broken links and poor navigation make your site appear neglected and unprofessional.
  • Regular Maintenance: Website optimization includes checking and fixing broken links regularly to maintain trust.

By addressing these issues with the help of professional web design services and focusing on website optimization, you can significantly enhance your site’s trustworthiness and user experience.


Trustworthiness is vital for the success of any website, impacting user experience, SEO rankings, and overall credibility. Enhancing your site’s trustworthiness leads to higher user satisfaction and better business outcomes.

Audit your website and make necessary improvements to enhance its trustworthiness. For professional assistance, consider partnering with Watermark Design, a leading web design and digital marketing company in Minnesota, to create a high-performing, reliable website.

Mark Haugtad
Mark Haugtad

Owner / Web Designer / SEO Enthusiast

Mark, founder of Watermark Design. With over 10 years of experience in Web Design & Development, Wordpress Services, Search Engine Optimization (SEO), Web Hosting, and Logo Design. Mark has always wanted to provide better quality service, affordability & support to local businesses. At Watermark Design, he performs in-depth research and collaborates with his talented team to give businesses advice they can trust. When Mark is not working you can find him hanging out with his wife, five children enjoying the Minnesota outdoors; hunting, fishing and camping.

Need Help With Your Website?